Features · Nº 05 · Trip-hop history
From Bristol to the Balearics
Bristol, Café del Mar and the records that never agreed to be calm
In the 1990s a sound built in Bristol’s sound systems was given a name nobody making it wanted, then packaged as a mood for sunsets, dinner parties and the morning after. The best records never quite agreed to be calm. This is the story of how they were made, how they were sold, and how a handful of DJs and compilers kept the tension audible, from a beatless mix at Café del Mar to a drum kit set up in a kitchen in Wales.
A few notes at sunset
A few notes of “Smokebelch II” are enough to put the rest of the room at a distance. The keyboard figure repeats, with a little rise at the end that keeps it from settling. The version I’m drawn to is the Beatless Mix by The Sabres of Paradise, the third selection on José Padilla’s first Café del Mar compilation in 1994. William Orbit’s “The Story of Light” comes before it and Penguin Cafe Orchestra’s “Music for a Found Harmonium” after it. On paper those are three different kinds of record. Padilla could hear what the end of one would do to the beginning of the next.12
There is a house record inside that melody. Its source is Elbee Bad’s “The New Age of Faith”, and the Sabres record exists in versions that put the drums back in front. On the mix Padilla chose, the drum has been taken away and you can still feel where it would land. Leaving it out exposes the melody. It is a small arrangement decision with a large consequence: a record made for a club becomes a record for the hour before the club.2
Now put on Massive Attack’s “Unfinished Sympathy”. The drums are there from the first bar and the strings pull against them for almost the whole record. Shara Nelson sounds as if she has been deciding for some time what to say and has finally decided to say it. There is the same sense of room around the melody, built from the opposite decision: everything is there, and the space survives anyway.
Both records ended up on the same shelf. By the end of the decade both could be bought on compilations sold as music to unwind to, and both were made by people who had spent their nights in front of loud speakers. That is the story here. A sound grew out of Bristol’s sound systems, with a bassline heavy enough to move a hall and voices that took their time over it. A magazine gave it a name its makers spent years refusing. A market turned the name into a mood. And a handful of selectors, Padilla at a café on the west coast of Ibiza, Morcheeba picking a mix of other people’s records, David Holmes on the radio, kept hearing what the mood left out. The Go! Team, at the far end, took the same sampler and the same breakbeats and refused to be calm at all.
Versions before the name
The Wild Bunch were a Bristol sound system before Massive Attack were a name on a sleeve. Andrew Vowles remembers Grant Marshall getting him a membership card for the Dug Out club when he was fifteen, so he could go to the hip-hop jams, and then following the crew to gigs around the country. The Wild Bunch came apart when Nellee Hooper left to work with Soul II Soul and Miles Johnson moved to America. In 1988 Marshall, Vowles and Robert Del Naja carried on as Massive Attack.3
In a sound system the people choosing, playing and talking over records have hours to make connections a listener at home might miss. Play a reggae record after a hip-hop import and you can carry the bass across or cut between two different ways of moving a room. Who takes the microphone, when the music drops out and which version goes on the deck are all part of the performance. By the time a record reaches the producer who wants to make something new from it, it has been handled in public many times.3
Bristol’s crews overlapped. Rob Smith remembers the Wild Bunch having their approach while others nearby developed theirs. Follow Smith & Mighty through two songs to hear what that meant. In 1988 they had Jackie Jackson sing “Walk On By” and “Anyone Who Had a Heart”, both familiar from Dionne Warwick, issued on their Three Stripe label as “Walk On” and “Anyone”. A listener already knew what those melodies did over a Bacharach and David arrangement. Smith & Mighty took most of the arrangement away and let the low end carry the feeling. With fewer cues telling you when a line will resolve, Jackson’s phrasing comes forward. She ends a line, leaves you with the bass, and comes back with the next thought. It is a dub instinct applied to a pop standard, and it sends you back to Warwick hearing how much of her meaning came from what surrounded her.4
One early Massive Attack twelve-inch gives the overlap a physical form. On the self-released “Any Love”, Carlton sings and Smith & Mighty share the production credit. The song takes a melody associated with Rufus and Chaka Khan into a Bristol studio with musicians and producers who would later be filed under different parts of dance music. The credits on that first issue show who was in touch with whom better than any diagram of subgenres.45
By 1991 Blue Lines could hold several kinds of voice. On “Safe From Harm” Shara Nelson sings against a bass figure lifted from Billy Cobham’s “Stratus”. The figure has enough momentum to run the track on its own; her lines cut across it, so the song seems to speed up while the groove holds still. It is a sound-system producer’s ear at work, choosing the one part of an old record that would keep its shape when looped. On “Five Man Army” several voices take turns, and the track changes when Horace Andy comes in: he can bend a note so slightly that the whole phrase moves with it. Hearing him there is a reminder that reggae’s place in this music was never only bass and echo. Massive Attack were working with a singer whose phrasing came out of a tradition of its own, and they gave him the album’s last word on “Hymn of the Big Wheel”.6
“Unfinished Sympathy” began smaller than it sounds. At the Coach House the group were working on another song when Nelson started singing over it. “The melody and the words started to come into shape,” she remembered. Her name is on the writing credit with Robert Del Naja, Grant Marshall, Andrew Vowles and Jonny Dollar. At Abbey Road, Wil Malone orchestrated the strings and Haydn Bendall engineered the session. Nelson’s idea had to be clear enough to survive a series of decisions that could easily have buried it, and one reason the record lasts is that you can follow her melody however much is going on around it.7
The strings have a restlessness of their own. In places the high parts press forward as though they could hurry a line Nelson wants to take her time over; then she reaches a word she wants to stretch and the balance tips back to her. The drums make both movements possible. With a pulse that firm an arrangement can grow very wide without the listener losing track of where the next line belongs. That is why Blue Lines made sense to people who knew the feeling of a big rig and to somebody listening alone, and why nobody at the time had a single word for it.
A name nobody asked for
The word arrived in June 1994. In Mixmag, a piece usually credited to Andy Pemberton used “trip hop” for DJ Shadow’s “In/Flux”, a Mo’ Wax twelve-inch: a Californian producer on James Lavelle’s London label, making an instrumental hip-hop track with the length and detail of a long club mix. A beat could lead into a change of scene without a verse to announce it, and a fragment became important through where it was placed. The writer was describing something new happening to hip-hop instrumentals. Within a year the term had been stretched to cover singers, Bristol groups and, eventually, whole racks of compilations.8
The people it was stretched over did not want it, and they said so for years. “Forget all that trip hop bullshit,” Andrew Vowles of Massive Attack told Mixmag in 1998. Geoff Barrow has said that when he first heard Portishead called trip-hop, he hated it. Tricky, two decades on, still opened an interview by saying he absolutely hated the term. The objection was not snobbery about a label. “Trip hop” suggested something to drift off to, and very little on these records was made for drifting. Blue Lines came out of sound systems; Dummy is about desire and damage; Maxinquaye is often frightening. The name won anyway, because it was useful to everyone except the musicians, and the rest of the decade is partly the story of the music pulling against its own description.9
Portishead’s Dummy, released that August, shows how much craft went into sounding found. Geoff Barrow and Adrian Utley remember wanting new playing to sound as if it came from an old record. They would play a part, put distance between it and the performance through the recording chain, then sample it as though it were someone else’s. A piece of music could acquire age and wear before any listener had touched it. “Sour Times” is built on “The Danube Incident”, from Lalo Schifrin’s More Mission: Impossible, with a sample of Smokey Brooks’s “Spin It Jig” beside it. The loop brings an atmosphere with a history in television scoring. Beth Gibbons gives it new stakes: the start of a phrase measured and controlled, the end sounding as though she has let out more than she meant to.1011
The name won anyway, because it was useful to everyone except the musicians
Barrow and Utley were still arguing with the chillout reading of the album twenty-five years later, when they told the Guardian that Dummy was never a chillout record. Gibbons sings about desire, damage and the terms on which people let each other close. On “Roads” the pace is slow enough for a held note to register in all its exposure. Put it on in a room where everyone is talking and it is likely to bring someone back to the singer.10
A month later Massive Attack released Protection. On the title track Tracey Thorn sings close to the listener, an unusually plain performance for a large record. The beat leaves room for the ends of her phrases, and the title turns up in different emotional positions as the song goes on: telling somebody you can look after them is not the same as admitting how much you want to. In 1995 Mad Professor answered with No Protection, a whole album of dubs. On “Radiation Ruling the Nation” the singer becomes something you infer from the pieces that come back. A short vocal ends and leaves a trail that turns into rhythm. On the song you follow the reassurance from line to line; in the dub you live in the hesitation between them. Two records sat side by side in the shops, and a listener could change their mind about which one was the centre.12
Tricky’s Maxinquaye, in February 1995, puts the voice in a far less settled place. On “Overcome” Martina Topley-Bird makes a few words feel as if they have their own temperature, and Tricky’s close, overlapping phrase pulls you into the space between the two. Topley-Bird’s own account is a reminder of how much of that intimacy was her performance rather than an effect.13
“Hell Is Round the Corner” and “Glory Box” go to the same Isaac Hayes passage, from “Ike’s Rap II”. You can start either track expecting the same low, rolling sound and end somewhere else. Portishead give Gibbons a space she can fill and then push against. Tricky makes the repetition feel boxed in, the orchestration coming back whatever the voices do to get out. Sample choice is where the comparison starts, not where it ends: which notes survive the loop, who sings over it and what the drums do to its scale is where each record gets its character.1014
“Black Steel” makes the case from another angle. Tricky and Topley-Bird took Public Enemy’s “Black Steel in the Hour of Chaos” into a track driven by live rock playing; engineer and producer Mark Saunders has described how it was built. The startling part is hearing Topley-Bird carry words most listeners knew in Chuck D’s voice. The lyric is intact and the change in timbre and force puts you in a different relation to the story. Chuck D will turn up again at the end of this article, on a Go! Team record.15
Then, in 1996, DJ Shadow released Endtroducing..... on Mo’ Wax, an album assembled from other records, with the patience of “In/Flux” stretched across an hour. It mattered here for a reason that would take a few years to show. Bristol had used samples as the ground under a singer. Shadow made the sample collage the whole story, and that idea would travel a long way from anything anyone called trip-hop.16
By Mezzanine, in April 1998, Massive Attack were testing how heavy the room could get, and it is hard not to hear the album partly as an answer to the shelf they had been put on. “Angel” starts with a bass figure that holds its position while the track gathers force. Horace Andy is given the opening bars for a fragile, almost pleading tone, and as the arrangement grows louder around him his voice becomes the one fixed point. The scale changes so gradually that you follow the bass and only later notice how much pressure has built. It is a slow record that feels like a physical confrontation.17
“Teardrop” uses the same weight differently. A repeated keyboard figure and the movement of the drums set a pattern Elizabeth Fraser can ride without bending her phrases to the obvious accents. She drifts across the middle of the track and leaves a syllable hanging while the machinery carries on underneath. Heard next to “Angel”, the lightness of her melody is plain, and so is how much both singers depend on what the low end is doing. The record was everywhere within a year, often in the company of music made to be ignored. It was not made to be ignored.1718
It was not made to be ignored.
Selling the calm
The market for quiet electronic music had its own roots, and they were not in Bristol. The KLF’s Chill Out in 1990 had shown that an album with no beat at all could belong to dance culture. In 1994 Pete Lawrence and Katrina Larkin started The Big Chill as ambient Sunday gatherings at the Union Chapel in Islington, and the next year took it outdoors to the Black Mountains in Wales, turning the chillout room into an event of its own. And the same year as Café del Mar Volumen Uno, the idea of an after-hours record that still had drums was arriving from several directions at once.1920
George Evelyn of Nightmares on Wax has described hearing Chill Out and wondering what a hip-hop version of it would be. Smokers Delight, released on Warp in 1995, is his answer. The drums stay present enough to keep heads nodding; “Nights Introlude” sets the pace early and tells you the album expects you to spend some time with it. It is a useful counterweight to the idea that “chilled” meant passive. Evelyn was making a hip-hop record for a particular hour, and you can hear the consistency of his decisions about drums and bass all the way down.21
By 1998 the hour had become a market. The K&D Sessions, Kruder & Dorfmeister’s double album of remixes, came out of Vienna on !K7 that autumn, and Air’s Moon Safari came out of Paris. Each was excellent on its own terms, and together they helped make a soft, expensive-sounding downtempo the default background of bars, shops and dinner parties. The Café del Mar series, now numbered and annual, sat on the same shelves. It became easy to hear the whole sound as background, and some of the music sold under it was made to be exactly that.
What makes the period worth going back to is that the good records were still in the racks beside the bland ones, and the people with the best ears kept finding them. A selector could put a Massive Attack remix beside a house record and a film theme and make each sound more like itself. Two of the clearest cases are a band whose own records were among the easiest to file as background, and a DJ whose name went on the compilations.
Skye Edwards and the sound of Big Calm
Morcheeba made the calmest records in this story, and there is no point pretending otherwise. What keeps them interesting is range rather than tension: how much they could fit inside a quiet song, and how far their taste reached once the song was finished.
Ross Godfrey remembers “Trigger Hippie” as the first piece Morcheeba recorded with Skye Edwards. He had been looking for a way to put a voice into the music he was making with his brother Paul, and the voice they found changed the music. Edwards sang quietly, so it made sense to pull back what was happening around her. It is worth holding on to that order of events. You could hear their debut, issued by China Records in October 1995, and assume the brothers made a soft track and found a singer to match. Godfrey’s account gives the singer a hand in deciding the sound of the band before they had finished their first album.22
Morcheeba made the calmest records in this story, and there is no point pretending otherwise.
“Trigger Hippie” has a dry humour and a strong internal balance. A singer with more power might have pushed the arrangement to answer the end of every line. Edwards can finish a phrase just before you expect and keep your attention on the sound she has left. The production has to decide how long to stay quiet for that small interval to register. On Who Can You Trust? in 1996 you can already hear a band comfortable with those decisions: a group that loves bass and drums, with a lead voice that gives them a reason to hold something back.2223
By Big Calm in 1998 Morcheeba were making space for ideas that take longer to explain than to hear. “Part of the Process” began as a country idea. In Paul Godfrey’s account Ross was on guitar, an EMS Synthi was to hand and the loops were going round. The country feel comes partly from the lift in the guitar and partly from the unhurried conviction of the vocal, and the loop lets both repeat without meeting the same way every time.24
“The Sea” was built from the drums up. Ross played the guitar in one take after a visit to the pub, through a wah pedal into the Mackie desk, and the high end was taken off in the mix. Steve Bentley-Klein arranged the strings and Edwards wrote the melody. Keep that sequence in mind next time the opening comes round. A guitar that could have announced itself with a bright edge instead sits inside the beat; the strings come in a little further back; and the singer has room to make an ordinary observation sound like something she has just decided to confide.24
Set it beside Nelson’s melody for “Unfinished Sympathy” and the difference is instructive. Both start with a singer bringing a tune that sets the course of the recording, and both have a team spending a long time on what goes around it. Nelson’s melody invites the arrangement to rise to meet it. Edwards’s voice makes an arrangement settle, so a guitar with its brightness rolled off can lead. With a title like “The Sea” the scale is already there, and the singer is free to notice something small on the shore.724
Period reviewers heard different albums. Billboard heard Gram Parsons and the early Eagles; The Irish Times compared Edwards with Beth Gibbons. Put “The Sea” beside “Part of the Process” and then the instrumental “Bullet Proof”, built on an old library-record break, and the readings start to fit together. Morcheeba’s idea of what belonged in one sleeve was wider than the shelf they were filed on. “Blindfold” was first written with a film in mind, and the band eventually got the strings to sit with the beat by sampling and shifting parts of the performance into place. “Let Me See” sets a loop built on an Akai S950 against Dom Pipkin’s keyboards and the flute of Jimmy Hastings, a player from the Canterbury scene whom Godfrey knew through a studio in Kent. Knowing someone who could play a good line, and knowing how to turn that line into a loop, carried equal weight.2423
The clearest evidence of that width is Morcheeba’s Back to Mine selection from 2001. It opens with Annette Peacock’s “Pony”, then Morcheeba’s own “On the Rhodes Again”, then Alice Russell’s “Someday”, Dr. John’s “Gris Gris Gumbo Ya Ya” and Jim White’s “Still Waters”; later come New Kingdom, David McCallum and Taj Mahal. If you came to it knowing the band from “The Sea”, they were ready to spend your first few minutes on something else entirely. Here was a band whose own records were easy to file as background, given a mix with their name on it, and filling it with avant-garde jazz singing, New Orleans voodoo, Southern gothic songwriting, a hip-hop group and a 1960s instrumental record by an actor. That is a selector’s answer to the shelf.25
What Padilla heard between the records
José Padilla’s recollections of Ibiza describe long hours at the decks and the freedom to play soul, jazz, funk, rock and electronic records side by side. That matters for how to hear the compilations. A listener coming to the numbered series late might assume the café had found a formula and commissioned records to fit it. The early volumes sound like something else: one person’s taste, built over long sunset sets, with many ways past the end of a familiar record. A cassette or a CD carried one version of that into a house or a car, and you could still recognise the person choosing.26
It was also a Balearic habit older than the café’s compilations. The Goa Mix in this series follows the same instinct from Paul Oakenfold’s side, coming home from Ibiza in the late 1980s convinced that atmosphere mattered more than genre.
On Volumen Uno, Sun Electric give way to Leftfield’s “Fanfare of Life” at track six, a few places on from “Smokebelch II”. It is one of the records I go back to from the first volume. Leftfield’s club records were heavy by design, a story The Long Way Round tells from the dancefloor, and here one sits in a programme that has already allowed a film-like piece by William Orbit, a Sabres mix with the beat taken out and an acoustic instrumental. The beat can come or go and the listener keeps their place. Later in the same volume A Man Called Adam’s “Estelle” and Underworld’s “Second Hand” give listeners who knew British dance music familiar names in a quieter setting. By then Padilla has offered several answers to how much rhythm a track needs to feel as though it is going somewhere.1
On 1995’s Volumen Dos my pick is Salt Tank’s “Sargasso Sea”, track eight. It was already on the group’s 1994 ST3 double twelve-inch for Internal, among other tracks the duo had chosen as a statement of their own. Padilla’s disc puts it into an argument about pace made by a DJ. Hearing it in both settings shows why the compilation version can become the one a listener imagines first.2728
By Volumen Cinco in 1998 the series was a fixture, and Padilla’s choices show how much of the decade’s music he could still make sound like itself. The standout for me is Levitation’s “More Than Ever People”, which starts straight after A.R. Rahman’s “Mumbai Theme Tune”: film music, then a sustained vocal track, with most of the compilation still to go. Further in is Les Négresses Vertes’ “Face à la mer” in Massive Attack’s full remix, at track nine and opening side C of the UK double LP. The remix had already appeared in the French group’s early-1990s remix catalogue, so a listener could reach it from either direction: following Massive Attack into their twelve-inches, or following Padilla through a compilation. Around it he places Electribe 101’s “Talking With Myself ’98” in the Canny remix, Kruder & Dorfmeister’s remix of Lamb’s “Transfatty Acid”, Nookie featuring Larry Heard, The Ballistic Brothers and Salt Tank again, with the José Padilla & Sunchild remix of “Angels Landing”. Massive Attack released Mezzanine the same year. A listener who bought both would have heard the same credit doing two opposite jobs.2930
That is the difference between a selector and a mood. Evelyn could arrive at an after-hours record through production, letting each track shape the next. Padilla had only records other people had made and the order he put them in, and he used that order to keep each record distinct rather than to blend them into one colour.
David Holmes, from Belfast to New York
David Holmes is another artist I love, and the two “Smokebelch II” mixes give him a way into this story. The Sabres’ catalogue lists the Beatless Mix and a separately titled David Holmes Mix, and his mix is one route from Padilla’s first volume back to records about how long a scene can hold its tension before something has to change.231
Holmes came to it through acid house. With Iain McCready he ran Sugar Sweet in the Conor Hall of Belfast Art College, and he remembers going to a North London club run by the Drum Club’s Charlie Hall, in 1991 as he tells it, and hearing Andrew Weatherall move through Balearic records, acid house and Detroit in one set. “The penny dropped,” he has said; he wanted Weatherall in Belfast. That is the connection in its simplest form: one DJ hearing another and wanting his own room to hear it too. Weatherall went on finding things to do with Holmes’s records, and his full-length instrumental mix of “I Heard Wonders” is the place to hear the acid side of that friendship. Holmes’s own first Essential Mix, in June 1995, is the place to hear how much of his taste was still machine rhythm before the funk of the later set took over.32333435
On Let’s Get Killed in 1997, the New York voices Holmes recorded in the street come through as people already in the middle of their lives, with their own rhythms of speech and their own sense of how loud to be. The samples are short enough to belong to the structure and long enough to put a place in your head, while the drums keep a steadier pace of their own. The Irish Times heard a funkier record than his debut, which is one way of describing a producer letting street recordings, funk and club production share one album.36
The best way to hear how far Holmes could travel is his Essential Mix for Radio 1 in June 1997. When Radio 1 chose ten classic Essential Mixes in 2010 to represent the series, it was one of them, alongside Oakenfold’s Goa Mix. In one run Ray Barretto and Joe Bataan give way to Harlem River Drive, Mandingo and Dick Hyman; Ananda Shankar’s “Streets of Calcutta” comes a little later, and it ends with Jimi Hendrix’s “Crosstown Traffic”. It moves forward the way a dance programme does, but through changes in the colour and attack of the records rather than a steady beat. Anyone who knows James Brown’s “Give It Up or Turnit a Loose” will have the record in their head before Dick Hyman’s version comes in; a DJ can use that half-second of recognition and let the actual record overturn it. Padilla might follow a rhythm out of a quiet selection; Holmes gives the ear a harder turn, a new bit of percussion or a different idea of what an electric instrument can do.37
On Bow Down to the Exit Sign in 2000, Holmes talked about Bitches Brew and old funk records, and the album came together with a film script in view. “Outrun”, with Martina Topley-Bird, brings the voice from Maxinquaye into a setting with a different producer and different concerns. You can follow her decisions about where to let a line hover and where to make it sharply present. The album format does for Holmes what the compilation does for Padilla: it gives him long enough to follow one track’s implications into the next, and to move towards film without asking every piece to be a song.3638
The Go! Team put the drums in the kitchen
The idea Endtroducing..... set loose did not stay sombre. In November 2000, in Australia, The Avalanches released Since I Left You, an album built almost entirely from other people’s records that sounded like a party rather than a comedown. The same year, Ian Parton’s The Go! Team issued their first record, the Get It Together EP on Pickled Egg, and Memphis Industries put out Blue States’ Nothing Changes Under the Sun. Sample collage had found its way out of the chillout room and into daylight.394041
The label link is the cleanest way in. Four years before Memphis Industries released Thunder, Lightning, Strike, it released Andy Dragazis’s Blue States album, and “Your Girl” is a good record to hear first. The melody has a clean outline even when the surrounding sounds blur its edges, and the rhythm does just enough to keep it moving while small changes in texture carry the interest. It is easy to imagine it in the middle of a set, after a big vocal and before something that needs air. Filed by how loud you would play them, Blue States and The Go! Team sit far apart. On the same label, they turn out to share an instinct about how long to stay with a tune and how much of its surroundings to leave audible.41
The early “Get It Together” has a children’s recorder and a guitar, with hip-hop samples in the picture. The recorder keeps the whole thing slightly off-centre; it can sound like someone playing for themselves until the drums make it possible to imagine a crowd. For Thunder, Lightning, Strike Parton took his equipment to his parents’ house in Wales and set the drum kit up in the kitchen. The sampler was an Akai S1000, alongside a reel-to-reel and a calculator for working out how far a sample had to be stretched. He wanted the room’s “clatteryness” in the record. A producer chasing a kit sound that would fit any track would spend time removing a kitchen’s clatter. Parton kept it, because it gave the new playing the same presence and wear as the old sources around it, the same trick Portishead had played from the other direction.4042
He has talked about the drums and his own melodies as the heart of the album. Changing the pitch of a fragment changes its relation to everything around it and its emotional character with it. On “Get It Together” the recorder hook arrives with the instrument’s wavering intact. “Ladyflash” puts the method under more pressure: voices close enough to shout back at, sounds that seem to come from across the room, all given a shared sense of movement. Parton’s account of making it leads back to his habit of finding sources in very different places and his enjoyment of recording outside a studio. His reference points run from New York guitar bands to old rap, soundtracks and double Dutch chants. Barrow and Utley made new playing sound recovered; Parton goes further and makes the sources collide. Neither is calm.424043
The album’s success brought a second set of decisions. When it was licensed for wider release in 2005 some material was recreated or replaced, and “Huddle Formation” is the quickest way to tell the editions apart. The 2004 version uses a sampled chant about skateboarding; the 2005 version has a chorus with new words written by Ninja and sung by session singers. Both are recognisably “Huddle Formation”, with the shape and force of the chant kept, and comparing them shows how changing a few lines alters the picture of a time and place without touching the energy.40
Ninja’s arrival in the live band mattered as much. A shout that sounds on record like the trace of something happening elsewhere becomes an instruction somebody on stage knows how and when to give, and the crowd takes a part in the arrangement too. Early coverage of the touring band had to describe the two drummers and the rapper to explain how the music worked. A record made by putting performances and samples together in private had become a way for a group of people to play together in public.4340
By Proof of Youth in 2007 that shift is plain. Sub Pop’s account stresses live instrumentation and voices, with samples further back. The Double Dutch Divas are in the cast, and Chuck D appears on “Flashlight Fight”. Across that record and Tricky’s “Black Steel” you can follow two very different routes into a voice that was already in the listener’s head: one by borrowing the words, the other by inviting the man.4415
It is worth ending a run through Thunder, Lightning, Strike with “Everyone’s a V.I.P. to Someone”. After the clipped demands of “The Power Is On”, it lets the melody come forward and shows what has been holding the album together through all the changes of volume and scenery. That is where a playlist can take you back to Blue States, and back further, to the beatless “Smokebelch II”: three records that seem to ask for different parts of the day and share an instinct for leaving a tune exposed.4041
What stays in my listening
When I think about the chilled side of ONEZERØFOUR, the records in this story are the ones I reach for, and they get there by different routes. The keyboard on the Sabres record and the voice on the Levitation track carry very different kinds of tune. With David Holmes, a piece of somebody’s conversation can make a track feel as though it started halfway through a story. With The Go! Team a small melody can sound as if it has come out of a much bigger scene.
What I keep hearing across them is how much a few decisions can do. Leave room for part of a phrase after the singer has gone. Give the bass something worth repeating. Let a recording keep a little of the texture of where it came from. And don’t let “chilled” mean nothing is at stake. Those are the things I listen for, and they matter to the quieter music I release.45
They run through the downtempo records in the catalogue. The Light That Never Goes Out belongs to that style: slow, heavy at the bottom, built around the weight of a voice. The Blurred Edge holds both halves of this article’s title, “Velvet Static” leaning towards Bristol and “Glass Harbor” towards the sunset. Static on the Concrete takes the cinematic side that runs through Dummy and Holmes’s film-minded albums. On Nocturnes Électriques, “Dead Air” is the downbeat, chilled one, closer to Morcheeba’s kind of downtempo than to anything with a rap in it.
The Go! Team influence is strongest in some of the more personal tracks I held back for Year One, and it comes through here and there across the story-inspired releases. “Return Channel”, also on Nocturnes Électriques, is where hip-hop and that Go! Team racket meet. “Havana Sleeps (Into the Night)”, on From Malecón to Midnight, sits between Morcheeba and The Go! Team, with spots of acid. What I recognise is the way a drum sound or a small melodic phrase can change the feel of a whole track, a tune coming through clearly with a lot going on around it, and a rough edge being part of what makes it personal. The acid records give me another way in, through a beat and a line that keep changing the longer I stay with them; on the same release, “Closer to the Light (SIB Rework)” is where that side and this one meet.
I’d go back to the beginning of Padilla’s first volume for what that means in practice. “Smokebelch II” has a satisfying sense of completion on its own. Play the next selection and the pause it left becomes part of something longer. Follow that feeling out of the compilation and there is a route through Shara Nelson, Beth Gibbons, Martina Topley-Bird, Skye Edwards and the voices Holmes found walking through New York. Somewhere near the other end there is a man with a drum kit in his parents’ kitchen. You could start the story from any one of those records and find a different way through it, and none of them would let you fall asleep.
You could start the story from any one of those records and find a different way through it, and none of them would let you fall asleep.
Listening guide
Selected listening
| Record | Start here |
|---|---|
| The Sabres of Paradise | “Smokebelch II (Beatless Mix)” on Café del Mar Volumen Uno, then the separately titled David Holmes Mix |
| Smith & Mighty with Jackie Jackson | “Walk On” and “Anyone”, then Dionne Warwick’s “Walk On By” and “Anyone Who Had a Heart” |
| Massive Attack with Shara Nelson | “Safe From Harm” beside Billy Cobham’s “Stratus”, then “Unfinished Sympathy” |
| Massive Attack and Mad Professor | “Protection” followed by “Radiation Ruling the Nation” |
| Portishead and Tricky | “Glory Box” followed by “Hell Is Round the Corner”, then “Black Steel” |
| DJ Shadow | “In/Flux”, then Endtroducing..... |
| Massive Attack, 1998 | “Angel” and “Teardrop” from Mezzanine; Massive Attack’s remix of “Face à la mer” from the same year |
| Nightmares on Wax | Smokers Delight, from “Nights Introlude” |
| Morcheeba | “Trigger Hippie”, “The Sea”, “Part of the Process” and the opening run of Back to Mine |
| José Padilla’s Café del Mar selections | “Fanfare of Life” on Uno, “Sargasso Sea” on Dos, then “More Than Ever People” and “Face à la mer” on Cinco |
| David Holmes | Let’s Get Killed, the June 1997 Essential Mix, and “Outrun” with Martina Topley-Bird |
| Andrew Weatherall and the acid side | “I Heard Wonders” (Weatherall instrumental), Weatherall’s remix of BP Fallon & David Holmes’s “Henry McCullough”, and Daniel Avery’s Drone Logic |
| The Balearic thread now | Pete Herbert’s Music for Swimming Pools and Reverso 68 with Phil Mison; Adam Port’s “Corrosive Love”; Alan Dixon’s “Take a Trip”; Port and Dixon’s “Forms of Love” |
| The Avalanches, Blue States and The Go! Team | Since I Left You, “Your Girl”, “Get It Together”, “Ladyflash” and “Everyone’s a V.I.P. to Someone” |
The records in the story
- Smokebelch II Beatless MixThe Sabres of Paradise · Sabres of Paradise · 1993 YouTube
- The Story of LightWilliam Orbit · I.R.S. · 1990 YouTube
- Music for a Found HarmoniumPenguin Cafe Orchestra · Editions EG · 1984 YouTube
- The New Age of FaithElbee Bad · Nu Groove YouTube
- Unfinished SympathyMassive Attack · Wild Bunch / Circa · 1991 YouTube
- Walk OnSmith & Mighty featuring Jackie Jackson · Three Stripe · 1988 YouTube
- AnyoneSmith & Mighty featuring Jackie Jackson · Three Stripe · 1988 YouTube
- Walk On ByDionne Warwick · Scepter · 1964 YouTube
- Anyone Who Had a HeartDionne Warwick · Scepter · 1963 YouTube
- Any LoveMassive Attack featuring Carlton · Massive Attack Records · 1988 YouTube
- Safe From HarmMassive Attack · Wild Bunch / Circa · 1991 YouTube
- StratusBilly Cobham · Atlantic · 1973 YouTube
- Five Man ArmyMassive Attack · Wild Bunch / Circa · 1991 YouTube
- Hymn of the Big WheelMassive Attack · Wild Bunch / Circa · 1991 YouTube
- In/FluxDJ Shadow · Mo' Wax · 1993 YouTube
- Sour TimesPortishead · Go! Beat · 1994 YouTube
- The Danube IncidentLalo Schifrin YouTube
- RoadsPortishead · Go! Beat · 1994 YouTube
- ProtectionMassive Attack featuring Tracey Thorn · Wild Bunch / Circa · 1994 YouTube
- Radiation Ruling the NationMassive Attack v Mad Professor · Wild Bunch / Circa · 1995 YouTube
- OvercomeTricky featuring Martina Topley-Bird · 4th & Broadway / Island · 1995 YouTube
- Hell Is Round the CornerTricky · 4th & Broadway / Island · 1995 YouTube
- Glory BoxPortishead · Go! Beat · 1994 YouTube
- Ike’s Rap IIIsaac Hayes · Enterprise · 1971 YouTube
- Black SteelTricky · 4th & Broadway / Island · 1995 YouTube
- Black Steel in the Hour of ChaosPublic Enemy · Def Jam · 1988 YouTube
- Midnight in a Perfect WorldDJ Shadow · Mo' Wax · 1996 YouTube
- AngelMassive Attack · Circa / Virgin · 1998 YouTube
- TeardropMassive Attack · Circa / Virgin · 1998 YouTube
- Chill OutThe KLF · KLF Communications · 1990 YouTube
- Nights IntroludeNightmares on Wax · Warp · 1995 YouTube
- Bug Powder Dust Kruder & Dorfmeister SessionBomb the Bass · !K7 · 1998 YouTube
- La Femme d’ArgentAir · Source / Virgin · 1998 YouTube
- Trigger HippieMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1996 YouTube
- Part of the ProcessMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1998 YouTube
- The SeaMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1998 YouTube
- Bullet ProofMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1998 YouTube
- BlindfoldMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1998 YouTube
- Let Me SeeMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1998 YouTube
- PonyAnnette Peacock · RCA · 1972 YouTube
- On the Rhodes AgainMorcheeba · China / Indochina · 1998 YouTube
- SomedayAlice Russell YouTube
- Gris Gris Gumbo Ya YaDr. John · Atco · 1968 YouTube
- Still WatersJim White · Luaka Bop YouTube
- Fanfare of LifeLeftfield · Hard Hands YouTube
- EstelleA Man Called Adam YouTube
- Second HandUnderworld YouTube
- Sargasso SeaSalt Tank · Internal · 1994 YouTube
- Mumbai Theme TuneA.R. Rahman · 1995 YouTube
- More Than Ever PeopleLevitation YouTube
- Face à la mer Massive Attack RemixLes Négresses Vertes · Delabel YouTube
- Talking With Myself ’98 Canny RemixElectribe 101 · 1998 YouTube
- Transfatty Acid Kruder & Dorfmeister RemixLamb · Fontana YouTube
- Angels Landing José Padilla & Sunchild RemixSalt Tank YouTube
- Smokebelch II David Holmes MixThe Sabres of Paradise · Sabres of Paradise · 1993 YouTube
- I Heard Wonders Weatherall Full Length Instrumental MixDavid Holmes · Go! Beat · 2000 YouTube
- My Mate PaulDavid Holmes · Go! Beat · 1997 YouTube
- Give It Up or Turnit a LooseJames Brown · King · 1969 YouTube
- Streets of CalcuttaAnanda Shankar · EMI · 1975 YouTube
- Crosstown TrafficThe Jimi Hendrix Experience · Track / Reprise · 1968 YouTube
- OutrunDavid Holmes featuring Martina Topley-Bird · Go! Beat · 2000 YouTube
- Since I Left YouThe Avalanches · Modular · 2000 YouTube
- Your GirlBlue States · Memphis Industries · 2000 YouTube
- Get It TogetherThe Go! Team · Memphis Industries · 2004 YouTube
- LadyflashThe Go! Team · Memphis Industries · 2004 YouTube
- Huddle FormationThe Go! Team · Memphis Industries · 2004 YouTube
- Flashlight FightThe Go! Team · Memphis Industries · 2007 YouTube
- The Power Is OnThe Go! Team · Memphis Industries · 2004 YouTube
- Everyone’s a V.I.P. to SomeoneThe Go! Team · Memphis Industries · 2004 YouTube
Notes
The numbered notes give the main sources behind particular passages: interviews with the people who made the records, release listings, period press and archived tracklists.
- Café del Mar, Volumen Uno, official compilation audio and tracklist and official album listing. ↩
- The Sabres of Paradise, Sabresonic (Remastered) catalogue and Beatless Mix listing. Resident Advisor, Sabresonic retrospective and Elbee Bad connection. ↩
- Bristol Museums, Massive Attack and The Wild Bunch collection notes. ↩
- Rob Smith interview, The Arts Desk. Bristol Archive Records, Three Stripe One. The Wire, Smith & Mighty and the Ashley Road sessions. ↩
- Discogs, Massive Attack featuring Daddy Gee and Carlton, “Any Love”, Massive Attack Records MASS 001, 1988, with Smith & Mighty credited as producers. ↩
- Blue Lines, release and recording credits. Radio Milwaukee, “Safe From Harm” and Billy Cobham’s “Stratus”. ↩
- Abbey Road Studios, “30 Years of Massive Attack’s ‘Unfinished Sympathy’”, including Nelson’s account of the rehearsal. ↩
- “Trip-Hop”, Mixmag, June 1994, reproduced by Solesides (the reproduction carries no byline; the attribution to Andy Pemberton is from later accounts) and by 88to98. Mo’ Wax release chronology. ↩
- Mixmag, Massive Attack, April 1998, from the archives. MusicRadar, Danny Scott’s interview with Geoff Barrow, 21 November 2025. Vice / THUMP, Ron Hart’s interview with Tricky, 13 June 2016. ↩
- KEXP, Geoff Barrow and Adrian Utley’s track-by-track account of Dummy. The Guardian, Barrow and Utley on Dummy and chillout. ↩
- “Sour Times”, samples and release. ↩
- Billboard, Protection contemporary coverage, 17 December 1994. Protection and No Protection release listing. ↩
- The Guardian, Martina Topley-Bird on recording with Tricky and finding her voice and Tricky and Topley-Bird revisit Maxinquaye. ↩
- “Glory Box”, session and sample notes. Pitchfork, Maxinquaye retrospective. ↩
- Sound on Sound, Mark Saunders on making Tricky’s “Black Steel”. ↩
- DJ Shadow, Endtroducing....., Mo’ Wax, UK release 16 September 1996 (US 19 November 1996). ↩
- The Guardian, Massive Attack’s “art of darkness”. WIRED, Mezzanine and the group’s move towards a heavier sound. ↩
- The Guardian, Elizabeth Fraser interview. NME, 1998 coverage of the Mezzanine sessions. ↩
- The KLF, Chill Out, 1990). ↩
- The Big Chill: Union Chapel gatherings from 1994, first outdoor event 1995). The Guardian, “My greatest mistake: Pete Lawrence”, 2010. The K&D Sessions, Studio !K7, 1998. ↩
- Warp and Nightmares on Wax, Smokers Delight. XLR8R, George Evelyn on The KLF and his idea of a hip-hop chillout record. ↩
- Official Charts, Morcheeba, “Trigger Hippie”, chart history. Roland, Ross Godfrey on meeting Skye Edwards and recording “Trigger Hippie”. ↩
- The Independent, 1998 profile of Skye Edwards and Morcheeba. Billboard, Big Calm coverage, 21 February 1998. The Irish Times, contemporary Big Calm review. ↩
- MusicRadar, Paul Godfrey on the making of Big Calm, track by track. ↩
- MusicBrainz, Back to Mine: Morcheeba, DMC BACKCD7, 23 July 2001. MixesDB, running order. ↩
- RA Exchange, José Padilla interview. DJ History archive, Padilla on his early sets and Café del Mar. ↩
- Café del Mar, Volumen Dos, official listings. ↩
- Discogs, Salt Tank, ST3, Internal, 1994, all editions; “Sargasso Sea” is on the second disc of the double twelve-inch. ↩
- Café del Mar, Volumen Cinco, official running order. Manifesto 565 228-1, UK double LP and side breaks. ↩
- Les Négresses Vertes, 10 Remixes 87–93 catalogue and Massive Attack mix credit. ↩
- The Sabres of Paradise, Beatless Mix and David Holmes Mix, listed separately. ↩
- Clash, “Defining Moments: David Holmes, Vendetta Suite & Timmy Stewart Talk Art College Memories”, 10 March 2022. The Guardian, Holmes and Iain McCready on Sugar Sweet and acid house in Belfast. Electronic Sound, Holmes on the Belfast Art College nights. ↩
- Disco Pogo, Holmes recalls hearing Andrew Weatherall and inviting him to Sugar Sweet. ↩
- “I Heard Wonders” (Weatherall Full Length Instrumental Mix), official audio and credit. Late Night Tales, BP Fallon & David Holmes, “Henry McCullough” (Andrew Weatherall Remix). ↩
- Essential Mixipedia, David Holmes’s Radio 1 mix from 18 June 1995 and its running order. ↩
- The Irish Times, 1997 review of Let’s Get Killed. The Observer, 2000 interview with David Holmes. ↩
- BBC Radio 1, The Essential Mix 500: the ten classic mixes chosen in 2010, including “15 June ’97: David Holmes Soul & Funk mix” (archived copy). BBC Radio International, historical guide to the Essential Mix. David Holmes, 15 June 1997, running order. ↩
- “Outrun”, label-supplied recording with Martina Topley-Bird’s credit. Exclaim!, contemporary review of Bow Down to the Exit Sign. ↩
- The Avalanches, Since I Left You, Modular, 27 November 2000; UK release on XL, 2001. ↩
- The Quietus, Ian Parton interview and Thunder, Lightning, Strike reissue feature. ↩
- Discogs, Blue States, Nothing Changes Under the Sun, Memphis Industries MI011CD / MI011LP, 2000. Blue States, Nothing Changes Under the Sun and anniversary reissue notes. ↩
- Bob Fischer, Ian Parton on the making of “Ladyflash”, originally published in Electronic Sound. ↩
- The Guardian, 2004 coverage of The Go! Team. Pitchfork, 2005 interview with Ian Parton. ↩
- Sub Pop, The Go! Team, Proof of Youth and its guests. ↩
- ONEZERØFOUR, artist discography and Bandcamp catalogue. ↩